Click to call 602-307-0808 24/7 Click Here for Free Consultation

Arizona Criminal Law

Will Joe Go? America’s Toughest Sheriff might be on the Ropes this Election

Sheriff Joe Arpaio, the self proclaimed “America’s toughest Sheriff”, might have a serious challenge today as voters head to the polls and determine if Maricopa County will keep Joe or bring in some new blood with candidate Paul Penzone.

After 20 years in office at Maricopa County Sheriff many in the community feel its time for a change. Citing years of civil suits against the department for inmate deaths, hundreds of un-investigated sex crime cases, and political bullying of judges and county supervisors the Sheriff’s opponents have grown louder and louder.

Current polls have it as a close race with many pundits saying its a toss up. We will know for sure by tomorrow.

What do you think? Should Sheriff Joe be reelected?

Dog Day in Supreme Court

The Supreme Court of the United States will hear arguments to determine whether drug sniffing dogs are an infringement on fourth amendment rights today. At stake is whether warrantless use of drug sniffing dogs are a violation of the fourth amendment of the United States constitution regarding unreasonable search and seizure.

Part of the debate will confront a ruling from a 2005 case where Judge Steven’s stated that a dogs nose does not violate human privacy so long as “no information other than the location of a substance that no individual has any right to possess.” The problem is that drug sniffing dogs are not 100% accurate and one study has even found that only 44% of the time drug dogs accurately find drug paraphernalia.

What do you think about drug dogs and privacy?

Arizona Attorney General’s Office Redacts Allegations about its Boss

Another week another story about Arizona politics in a disparaging light. This week is a follow up regarding the ongoing trouble for Arizona AG Tom Horne. As we posted on Oct 2nd Mr. Horne is in trouble for election misconduct when he may or may not have given instructions to an independent political group.

When Maricopa County Attorney Bill Montgomery came out with his offices report they included un-redacted memos. Some of these memos talked about a possible affair between Mr. Horne, a married man, and Assistant Attorney General Carmen Chenal, a long-time Horne employee and confidant.

Now the Arizona AG’s office has redacted those memos and many in the press and first amendement experts are crying foul. The AG’s office contends that the redacted memos simply protect its own employees from gossip and other distracting information that the public does not need to know about. The experts cite Horne’s own office policy on dealing with such circumstances where it agrees with a lower courts ruling that just because information may be embarrassing does not preclude it from public review.

Reading some of these memos is like a page out of a high school soap opera. What do you think are things out of control at the AG?

Sheriff Joe Sued over Inmates Death

Its a busy news week for Arizona, first the redacted memo’s at the AG’s office and now Sheriff Joe’s Office gets sued by the family of an inmate killed in custody last December. The civil suit claims that Ernest “Marty” Atencio was assaulted by officers after his arrest and collapsed and died 5 days later and seeks a Jury Trial and unspecified damages.

The timing for this suit is not good as the Sheriff is running for his sixth term in office and is getting decent competition from Paul Penzone. The case is the latest of numerous suits faced by Maricopa County lawman Arpaio, who styles himself “America’s Toughest Sheriff” and is known for sweeps to round up illegal immigrants and no-frills treatment of inmates in county jails.

A federal judge is expected to rule soon in another suit brought against Arpaio, this one a class-action case by five Hispanic citizens who claimed they were stopped by the sheriff’s deputies because of their ethnicity.

Welcome to the wild west!

Private prison company awarded Arizona Contract with 35% cost increase

Last week the Arizona Department of Corrections awarded a prison contract to Corrections Corporation of America(CCA). To no real surprise CCA employs lobbyists with close ties to Governor Jan Brewer. What is pretty shocking however is that by having CCA, a private company, run the prison instead of the state it will cost taxpayers 35% more.

So while government is getting smaller it is not getting cheaper. What’s even more wild is that government officials cite saving money because they state wont have to build a new prison, even though the facility at Eloy is already built.


CCA is based out of Nashville, Tennessee and will operate a 1000 bed medium security prison in Eloy with the option to run another 1000 beds if serious offender inmates increase in population. CCA, a publicly held company that reported $162.5million in profits last year, was one of five bidders for the contract. The firm is politically connected to Brewer, who has pushed for the prison expansion. Until mid-July, CCA employed Chuck Coughlin, an influential lobbyist who is a close friend and an adviser to Brewer. And, state lobbying records show CCA also employs Policy Development Group, a lobbying firm that includes Paul Senseman, Brewer’s former spokesman.

“If you place two of your lobbyists at the right and left hand of the governor of the state and she has the final say and oversight of the Department of Corrections, I would say that’s a pretty smart business strategy,” said Caroline Isaacs of the American Friends Service Committee, a Quaker group and opponent of Arizona’s private-prison expansion.

Steve Owen, a CCA spokesman, said the company won the bid through a rigorous procurement process, and he credited the support of Eloy and others in Pinal County for helping CCA win.

“A lot of companies bid for this contract. We were selected on the merits of our proposal,” Owen said. “CCA’s proposal provides Arizona an existing prison that is staffed by experienced corrections professionals, provides established rehabilitation programs, and meets and exceeds industry standards for safety and security.”

Bill Lamoreaux, a corrections spokesman, said lobbying firms had no influence on the decision-making process.

“The award was based on the evaluation of the proposals from the prospective vendors and was not influenced by lobbyists and/or consultants from any of the submitting firms. The award decision was the responsibility and decision of the Department of Corrections,” Lamoreaux said.

Attempts to reach Brewer’s office, Coughlin and Senseman were unsuccessful after the Department of Corrections announced just before 6 p.m. that that CCA had won the bid.

The state granted the contract even though Corrections records show that it’s cheaper for taxpayers to have the state run a prison. The move comes as the state’s overall prison population has declined the past two years, is expected to remain flat the next two years and then increase only slightly thereafter.

The contract calls for CCA to be paid a per diem rate of $65.43 per bed. The most recent information available shows the average daily cost per inmate in a state-run medium-custody facility in 2010 was $48.42. The award to CCA is 35percent more than what it cost the state to house and monitor inmates two years ago.

Corrections Director Charles Ryan has justified the extra cost for a private-prison operator because he said the state is not laying out additional cash to build a new prison, and the private firm needs to recover its cost for a facility.

However, CCA is not building a new prison in Eloy. Instead, it’s using an existing prison, according to Owen.

The contract calls for 500 beds to come online in January 2014. The next 500 would be in place in January 2015. The Legislature has not determined when, or if, the remaining 1,000 beds would be added, but the decision would be based on increases in the medium-security population.

If CCA operates the Eloy facility at 90percent of capacity for the 1,000 beds, it would make nearly $21.5million annually.

The company houses more than 80,000 inmates in more than 60 facilities, including six in Arizona. CCA’s Arizona facilities house inmates from other states. CCA board members include former U.S. Sen. Dennis DeConcini, D-Ariz., and Anne Mariucci, an Arizona Board of Regents member.

State corrections records, as of Friday, show there are 2,002 empty beds in Arizona’s prison system, which houses 39,843 male and female inmates in state-operated and private prisons.

The records show that 1,153 of the empty beds are in minimum-security facilities and 724 others are in women’s prisons. There’s a shortage of 31 medium-security prison beds.

Ryan has said despite the overall surplus of beds, the state cannot place medium-security inmates in minimum-security facilities because of safety concerns. Also, men cannot be housed in female prisons.

A group of elected officials, most of whom are Democrats, along with clergy members and representatives of civil-rights groups, this week asked Brewer to intervene and stop the contract. The governor, who supported the additional beds, declined.

“The bottom line is we need to protect safety while protecting taxpayer dollars, and expansion of private prisons does neither,” said state Rep. Chad Campbell, D-Phoenix.

Click Here for Free ConsultationComparison Questions to Ask when Hiring a Lawyer